Adobe InDesign vs QuarkXpress - advice needed Trådens avsändare: SST
|
|---|
SST 
Australien
Local time: 04:42
Engelska till Ukrainska
+ ...
Hello everyone,
I am considering undertaking a short course either in InDesign or QuarkXpress.
I am wondering which software is more popular as a tool to deliver DTP/translating projects, which one is more reliable, more user-friendly?
I have found an interesti... See more Hello everyone,
I am considering undertaking a short course either in InDesign or QuarkXpress.
I am wondering which software is more popular as a tool to deliver DTP/translating projects, which one is more reliable, more user-friendly?
I have found an interesting article:
http://www.creativepro.com/story/feature/14816.html?origin=story
but I would appreciate it if you could share your personal experience with me.
Thank you! ▲ Collapse
| | | | Roberta Anderson
Italien
Local time: 21:12
Medlem (2001)
Engelska till Italienska
+ ...
| InDesign and QXPress - gauge your clients' needs | Apr 20, 2004 |
Hi, Tanya.
InDesign is a much newer application compared to QXPress, and is rapidly gaining ground. Although QXPress is still more widespread than ID, ID is rapidly making its way within graphic studios and printers (I'm following an Italian mailing list for InDesign users, and most of the subscribers are also QXP users).
From your point of view, as with all other kind of sw applications, it is best to equip yourself according to your clients' needs. QXP files can be co... See more Hi, Tanya.
InDesign is a much newer application compared to QXPress, and is rapidly gaining ground. Although QXPress is still more widespread than ID, ID is rapidly making its way within graphic studios and printers (I'm following an Italian mailing list for InDesign users, and most of the subscribers are also QXP users).
From your point of view, as with all other kind of sw applications, it is best to equip yourself according to your clients' needs. QXP files can be converted to ID format, but not the other way round (as far as I am aware).
They are not too different in their approach, and when you master one of them it is easy to use the other one as well. For one client I get some docs in InDesign format and others in QXP format - I think they are starting to use InDesign internally, and are at present using it only for some documents, as gradual implementation. That is I think a typical approach (another client gives me some documents in PageMaker format and others in InDesign format, for the same reason). My duty as a translator is to return the files in the same format as I get them (the client may need to change images at a later stage, or formatting, so it is important that he receives back a format that he can use).
As neither is particularly cheap, I would invest in the one for which you have immediate request/need, so that its cost can be recouped within a few projects.
Until your actual need for either ID or QXP grows, some clients may accept a workaround, i.e. provide you with the text files exported from either QXP or ID which you can translate with Word, Trados or whatever, and the client will take care of any DTP task involved in flowing your translated text back into the original document.
So I would gauge your clients' current situation and future plans, and invest accordingly. They may themselves be in a transition phase of migrating from QXP to ID, so it would make more sense to invest in ID and use text exports for any jobs in QXP.
I personally much prefer ID, particularly in its new version - but then I might be biased!
HtH,
Roberta
[Edited at 2004-04-20 07:18] ▲ Collapse
| | | | SST
Australien
Local time: 04:42
Engelska till Ukrainska
+ ...
TOPIC STARTER
Hi Roberta,
you see, I don't have a specific assignment, I just want to extend my computer skills and offer more than translating/interpreting services.
I am interested in a short course advertised here in Adelaide, either IN or QX, and the price/length of the courses is the same, that makes my decision difficult
I would be using the demo version at home for the duration of the course, so at ... See more Hi Roberta,
you see, I don't have a specific assignment, I just want to extend my computer skills and offer more than translating/interpreting services.
I am interested in a short course advertised here in Adelaide, either IN or QX, and the price/length of the courses is the same, that makes my decision difficult
I would be using the demo version at home for the duration of the course, so at this stage the cost is not so important, but rather...which package is in greater demand, what translation/copywriting agencies are looking for.
Thank you for your detailed answer! I might just install the demo versions of both programs and play around with them before the courses start, to see which one I like more... ▲ Collapse
| | | | Roberta Anderson
Italien
Local time: 21:12
Medlem (2001)
Engelska till Italienska
+ ...
| choosing what course to attend | Apr 20, 2004 |
I see...
I would say that QXP is currently more widespread, but a large number of PageMaker and QXPress users are turnig to ID, so that in the future (1 or 2 yrs from now) ID will be more in demand (because it will be adopted by both PM and QXP users, while it is unlikely that PageMaker users will now shift to QXP).
Once you master one of them, though, it will be pretty easy to learn the other one.
ID has a user interface that's very similar to that used by Illustrator and Phot... See more I see...
I would say that QXP is currently more widespread, but a large number of PageMaker and QXPress users are turnig to ID, so that in the future (1 or 2 yrs from now) ID will be more in demand (because it will be adopted by both PM and QXP users, while it is unlikely that PageMaker users will now shift to QXP).
Once you master one of them, though, it will be pretty easy to learn the other one.
ID has a user interface that's very similar to that used by Illustrator and Photoshop. So that would be another advantage of attending an ID course...
HtH,
Roberta ▲ Collapse
| | | | To report site rules violations or get help, contact a site moderator: You can also contact site staff by submitting a support request » Adobe InDesign vs QuarkXpress - advice needed | Pastey | Your smart companion app
Pastey is an innovative desktop application that bridges the gap between human expertise and artificial intelligence. With intuitive keyboard shortcuts, Pastey transforms your source text into AI-powered draft translations.
Find out more » |
| | TM-Town | Manage your TMs and Terms ... and boost your translation business
Are you ready for something fresh in the industry? TM-Town is a unique new site for you -- the freelance translator -- to store, manage and share translation memories (TMs) and glossaries...and potentially meet new clients on the basis of your prior work.
More info » |
|
| | | | X Sign in to your ProZ.com account... | | | | | |
Login to reply/comment 
